Aller au contenu
  • Home
  • Teams
    • All lawyers
    • Employment law
    • Company and association law
    • Economic and commercial law
    • Banking and financial law
    • Real estate law
    • Public and administrative law
    • Liability and insurance law
    • Health law, financial criminal law, disciplinary law
    • Support
  • Sectors
    • Art, culture, heritage
    • Non-profit organisations
    • Sports associations and federations
    • Aviation
    • Banking-insurance-finance
    • Biotech
    • Consultancy
    • Water
    • Energy 
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Expats
    • Civil service
    • Hospitality industry 
    • Intermunicipal companies
    • Luxury goods
    • Media & Audiovisual
    • Public interest bodies
    • Public-private partnership (PPP)
    • Local authorities
    • Regulated professions and professional bodies
    • Public companies
    • Healthcare 
    • FPS
    • Start-ups and Scale-ups
    • Town planning
  • News
  • Events
  • Contact
Menu
  • Home
  • Teams
    • All lawyers
    • Employment law
    • Company and association law
    • Economic and commercial law
    • Banking and financial law
    • Real estate law
    • Public and administrative law
    • Liability and insurance law
    • Health law, financial criminal law, disciplinary law
    • Support
  • Sectors
    • Art, culture, heritage
    • Non-profit organisations
    • Sports associations and federations
    • Aviation
    • Banking-insurance-finance
    • Biotech
    • Consultancy
    • Water
    • Energy 
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Expats
    • Civil service
    • Hospitality industry 
    • Intermunicipal companies
    • Luxury goods
    • Media & Audiovisual
    • Public interest bodies
    • Public-private partnership (PPP)
    • Local authorities
    • Regulated professions and professional bodies
    • Public companies
    • Healthcare 
    • FPS
    • Start-ups and Scale-ups
    • Town planning
  • News
  • Events
  • Contact
  • en_GBEN
    • fr_FRFR
    • nl_NLNL
  • en_GBEN
    • fr_FRFR
    • nl_NLNL
  • Home
  • Teams
    • All lawyers
    • Employment law
    • Company and association law
    • Economic and commercial law
    • Banking and financial law
    • Real estate law
    • Public and administrative law
    • Liability and insurance law
    • Health law, financial criminal law, disciplinary law
    • Support
  • Sectors
  • News
  • Events
  • Contact
  • en_GBEN
    • fr_FRFR
    • nl_NLNL
Menu
  • Home
  • Teams
    • All lawyers
    • Employment law
    • Company and association law
    • Economic and commercial law
    • Banking and financial law
    • Real estate law
    • Public and administrative law
    • Liability and insurance law
    • Health law, financial criminal law, disciplinary law
    • Support
  • Sectors
  • News
  • Events
  • Contact
  • en_GBEN
    • fr_FRFR
    • nl_NLNL

NEWSLETTER MAY 2023 - REAL ESTATE LAW / End of the legal crusade led by a co-owner against a co-owners' association

News
19 MAY 2023

Real estate law

The Cour de Cassation confirms that an association of co-owners can sell the common parts of a building by a decision taken by a majority of four-fifths of the votes.

During a general meeting, the co-owners of a building in Woluwe-Saint-Pierre voted to transfer certain common parts of the building.

One of the co-owners, unhappy with this decision, then applied to the Justice of the Peace for the canton of Woluwe-Saint-Pierre to have the general meeting's decision overturned.

The plaintiff, whose claim was dismissed by the Justice of the Peace, then appealed this decision to the French-speaking Court of First Instance in Brussels.

As her appeal was rejected, the plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court against this decision.

Before the Court of Cassation, the plaintiff requests that the following two questions be referred to the Constitutional Court for a preliminary ruling:

  1. " Article 577-7 §1erThis is the case, for example, with the sale of the common parts of an immovable of which it is not itself the owner, thereby depriving the co-owner(s) refusing the sale of their property, does it violate articles 10, 11 and 16 of the constitution to institute a difference in treatment between co-owners of a building or group of buildings and owners of individual buildings, who cannot be forced to sell their building, in whole or in part? "

 

  1. " Article 577-7 §1er2° e) of the Civil Code, in that it allows the general meeting to sell, by a majority of four-fifths of the votes cast and not unanimously, and therefore, where applicable, against the wishes of one or more co-owners, common parts of the building of which it is not the owner, whereas any natural or legal person has the right to respect for his or her property and no one may be deprived of his or her property, except in the public interest, violate Article 16 of the Constitution? does it infringe Article 16 of the Constitution, in conjunction with Article 1 of the Constitution, which states that every natural or legal person has the right to respect for his or her property and that no one may be deprived of his or her property, except in the public interest?erparagraph 1erof the first additional protocol to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms? "

 

Article 16 of the Constitution states that :

"No one may be deprived of his property except in the public interest, in the cases and in the manner established by law, and subject to fair and prior compensation. ".

In its judgment of 18 November 2021, the Constitutional Court ruled that Article 577-7 §1, 2°, e), of the former Civil Code did not violate Article 16 of the Constitution.

In its ruling of 9 March 2023, the Cour de Cassation (French Supreme Court) stated that, while decisions to dispose of common areas must be taken by a four-fifths majority, a minority of co-owners may be deprived of their ownership rights against their will.

However, the Cour de Cassation emphasised that this deprivation of property rights is not without consideration, since a portion of the sale price is guaranteed to them and a judicial review procedure is provided for.

The Court of Cassation therefore dismissed the plaintiff's appeal on the grounds that ". article 577-7, §1er2°, e), of the former Civil Code strikes a fair balance between the imperatives of the general interest and those of protecting the right to respect for property. ".

After several years of proceedings during which we assisted the co-owners' association, it finally won its case, putting an end to the legal crusade led by one of the building's co-owners.

For more information, please contact Laurent Verbraken (laurent.verbraken@cew-law.be), Caroline Compagnon (caroline.compagnon@cew-law.be) and Eline De Mol (eline.demol@cew-law.be), lawyers, CEW & Partners.

Written by

Laurent Verbraken

Partner
Linkedin-in
laurent.verbraken@cew-law.be
+32 (0)2 542 02 45
Economic and commercial lawReal estate law

Caroline Compagnon

Counsel
Linkedin-in
caroline.compagnon@cew-law.be
+32 (0)2 542 02 37
Real estate law

Eline De Mol

Associate
Linkedin-in
eline.demol@cew-law.be
+32 (0)2 542 02 46
Real estate law

You will also like

News
5 SEPTEMBRE 2023

Stéphanie Colella devient Managing Partner

La rentrée est synonyme de changement chez CEW & PARTNERS avec la nomination de Me Stéphanie Colella comme ...
READ MORE
News
2 AOUT 2023

Actualités législatives en matière de lutte contre les nouveaux modes de fraude en ligne

Les fraudes en ligne sont en constante augmentation depuis 2019, comme en atteste notamment le rapport 2022 de l’Ombud...
READ MORE

Do you have a question or need advice?

Contact us!

Contact us

Sectors

  • Art, culture, heritage
  • Non-profit organisations
  • Sports associations and federations
  • Aviation
  • Banking-insurance-finance
  • Biotech
  • Consultancy
  • Water
  • Energy 
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Expats
  • Civil service
  • Hospitality industry 
  • Intermunicipal companies
  • Luxury goods
  • Media & Audiovisual
  • Public interest bodies
  • Public-private partnership (PPP)
  • Local authorities
  • Regulated professions and professional bodies
  • Public companies
  • Healthcare 
  • FPS
  • Start-ups and Scale-ups
  • Town planning
  • Art, culture, heritage
  • Non-profit organisations
  • Sports associations and federations
  • Aviation
  • Banking-insurance-finance
  • Biotech
  • Consultancy
  • Water
  • Energy 
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Expats
  • Civil service
  • Hospitality industry 
  • Intermunicipal companies
  • Luxury goods
  • Media & Audiovisual
  • Public interest bodies
  • Public-private partnership (PPP)
  • Local authorities
  • Regulated professions and professional bodies
  • Public companies
  • Healthcare 
  • FPS
  • Start-ups and Scale-ups
  • Town planning

Teams

  • All lawyers
  • Employment law
  • Company and association law
  • Economic and commercial law
  • Banking and financial law
  • Real estate law
  • Public and administrative law
  • Liability and insurance law
  • Health law, financial criminal law, disciplinary law
  • Support
  • All lawyers
  • Employment law
  • Company and association law
  • Economic and commercial law
  • Banking and financial law
  • Real estate law
  • Public and administrative law
  • Liability and insurance law
  • Health law, financial criminal law, disciplinary law
  • Support

Contact

Avenue Louise 250
1050 Brussels
Belgium

+32 (0)2 534 20 20

info@cew-law.be

Follow us

Linkedin-in
  • Anti-money laundering
  • Conditions of intervention
  • Transparency of fees and charges
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie policy (EU)
  • Anti-money laundering
  • Conditions of intervention
  • Transparency of fees and charges
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie policy (EU)

Developed by Le Sidecar Web

Managing cookie consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies such as cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Failure to consent or withdraw consent may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The storage or technical access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. Technical storage or access which is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. In the absence of a subpoena, voluntary compliance by your internet service provider or additional third party records, the information stored or retrieved for this sole purpose generally cannot be used to identify you.
Marketing
The storage or technical access is necessary to create user profiles in order to send advertisements, or to track the user on a website or on several websites with similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}