Aller au contenu
  • Home
  • Teams
    • All lawyers
    • Employment law
    • Company and association law
    • Economic and commercial law
    • Banking and financial law
    • Real estate law
    • Public and administrative law
    • Liability and insurance law
    • Health law, financial criminal law, disciplinary law
    • Support
  • News
  • Events
  • Contact
Menu
  • Home
  • Teams
    • All lawyers
    • Employment law
    • Company and association law
    • Economic and commercial law
    • Banking and financial law
    • Real estate law
    • Public and administrative law
    • Liability and insurance law
    • Health law, financial criminal law, disciplinary law
    • Support
  • News
  • Events
  • Contact
  • en_GBEN
    • fr_FRFR
    • nl_NLNL
  • en_GBEN
    • fr_FRFR
    • nl_NLNL
  • Home
  • Team
    • All lawyers
    • Employment law
    • Company and association law
    • Economic and commercial law
    • Banking and financial law
    • Real estate law
    • Public and administrative law
    • Liability and insurance law
    • Health law, financial criminal law, disciplinary law
    • Support
  • News
  • Events
  • Contact
  • en_GBEN
    • fr_FRFR
    • nl_NLNL
Menu
  • Home
  • Team
    • All lawyers
    • Employment law
    • Company and association law
    • Economic and commercial law
    • Banking and financial law
    • Real estate law
    • Public and administrative law
    • Liability and insurance law
    • Health law, financial criminal law, disciplinary law
    • Support
  • News
  • Events
  • Contact
  • en_GBEN
    • fr_FRFR
    • nl_NLNL

Publication of communal tax regulations, the Constitutional Court's clarification

Insights
26 JANUARY 2023

Public and administrative law

The decree was expected by practitioners, municipalities and taxpayers. The constitutionality of the mechanism implemented by the New Municipal Law (NLC) and the CDLD regarding the publication of the tax regulation was at stake. It was pronounced on 15 December 2022 (no. 16/2022).

The enforceability of a tax regulation against third parties is ensured in the Brussels and Walloon Regions by Articles 112 to 114 NLC and L1133-1 and 2 CDLD respectively. The tax regulation must be published and this publication must be recorded in a register specially kept for this purpose in the forms provided for by a Government order.

The forms of annotation in the register are defined in a Royal Decree of 14 October 1991, which requires that the annotation be made the day after the publication, in the order of the publications, dated and signed by the Mayor and the municipal secretary.

The Constitutional Court recalls the position of the Court of Cassation, which considers that the only admissible method of proof of the publication of a municipal ordinance or regulation is the annotation in the special register. It is also recalled that the annotation in the register relates to the evidential regime of the publication and not to the nullity of the regulation. The legal provisions, according to the Constitutional Court, are likely to be interpreted as including a condition of form on pain of the unenforceability of the regulation.

As for the annotation in the register as the only admissible proof of the enforceability of a regulation, the Court recalls that it is a question of the protection of the person concerned so that the legislator was able to conceive a unique and exclusive evidential regime.

The Court adds that the federal or Walloon legislator has provided for the method of publication and has defined the method of proof consisting of annotation in a register. This evidential exclusivity leading to the unenforceability and not the nullity of the regulation could be delegated to the executive as regards the form of the annotation. The legal empowerment is thus constitutional.

The Court also decides that the effect of the lack of annotation is on the enforceability of the regulation, so that the form of the annotation is not one of the essential elements of the tax, so that there is no violation of the principle of legality.

The Court considers that the existence of a single system of proof of publication is admissible in the same way as for regulations requiring publication in an official journal. It also considers that there is no discrimination between the regime of enforceability of municipal regulations and provincial regulations, which must be published in the Provincial Bulletin.

The lesson of the judgment is therefore clear. The legislator could choose a single method of publicising tax regulations, choose the mechanism of annotation in a register and empower the executive to determine the method of annotation. This method of publicity only has consequences for the enforceability of the tax regulation and is not contrary to the Constitution.

For more information, please contact Jean LAURENT (jean.laurent@cew-law.be), lawyer, CEW & Partners.

Written by

Jean Laurent

Partner
Linkedin-in
jean.laurent@cew-law.be
+32 (0)2 542 02 49
Public and administrative law

You will also like

News
26 MAY 2023

Town Planning Brussels - Retail in public amenity zones?

The PRAS reserves public interest or public service facility zones for buildings or installations that are in the public interest or...
READ MORE
Insights
22 MAY 2023

Speech by Marc-David Weinberger at the "Anti-Money Laundering - Compliance" conference on 22 May 2023

Marc-David Weinberger will be taking part in the Anti-Money Laundering - Compliance conference organised by the...
READ MORE

Do you have a question or need advice?

Contact us!

Contact us

Sectors

  • Inter-municipal public services
  • Hospitals and medical laboratories
  • Real estate
  • Aviation
  • Insurance
  • New technologies
  • Inter-municipal public services
  • Hospitals and medical laboratories
  • Real estate
  • Aviation
  • Insurance
  • New technologies

Teams

  • Lawyers
  • Employment law
  • Company and association law
  • Economic and commercial law
  • Banking and financial law
  • Real estate law
  • Public and administrative law
  • Liability and insurance law
  • Health law, financial criminal law, disciplinary law
  • Support
  • Lawyers
  • Employment law
  • Company and association law
  • Economic and commercial law
  • Banking and financial law
  • Real estate law
  • Public and administrative law
  • Liability and insurance law
  • Health law, financial criminal law, disciplinary law
  • Support

Contact

Avenue Louise 250
1050 Brussels
Belgium

+32 (0)2 534 20 20

info@cew-law.be

Follow us

Linkedin-in
  • Anti-money laundering
  • Conditions of intervention
  • Transparency of fees and charges
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie policy (EU)
  • Anti-money laundering
  • Conditions of intervention
  • Transparency of fees and charges
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie policy (EU)

Developed by Le Sidecar Web

Managing cookie consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies such as cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Failure to consent or withdraw consent may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The storage or technical access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. Technical storage or access which is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. In the absence of a subpoena, voluntary compliance by your internet service provider or additional third party records, the information stored or retrieved for this sole purpose generally cannot be used to identify you.
Marketing
The storage or technical access is necessary to create user profiles in order to send advertisements, or to track the user on a website or on several websites with similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}